DNA From a 1982 Fingerprint Card Closes 1978 Murder

Montana investigators say they are the first US agency to solve a homicide using DNA recovered from an old fingerprint booking card, closing the 1978 killing of Corina Contreraz.

@sharedot

DNA From a 1982 Fingerprint Card Closes 1978 Murder

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • True Crime
  • Cold Case
  • Forensic Genealogy
  • Montana

Montana investigators say they are the first US agency to solve a homicide using DNA recovered from an old fingerprint booking card, closing the 1978 killing of Corina Contreraz.

Nearly 48 Years Later, a Name

At a press conference in Billings on Thursday, Yellowstone County Sheriff Kent O'Donnell identified Angelo James Stallsmith Sr. as the man responsible for the December 1978 homicide of 16-year-old Corina Lydia Contreraz, whose body was found on Pryor Creek Road east of Billings.

She was last seen around 3 a.m. leaving a friend's home near South Park; hours later, a school bus driver spotted her body near the Interstate 90 interchange. For nearly 48 years, the only public facts about her death were written on her death certificate.

"It's finally over," said her last living sister, Jennifer Contreraz, wiping away tears.

The Surprising First: DNA Off a Fingerprint Card

The twist that makes this case a true-crime first: investigators say they recovered Stallsmith's DNA from a fingerprint booking card he pressed his fingers to after a 1982 vehicle-theft arrest, then matched it to evidence from the crime scene.

According to Forensic Magazine, Yellowstone County believes it is the first law enforcement agency in the United States to solve a homicide using DNA recovered from an old fingerprint card.

Forensic Magazine also reports the cards were nearly destroyed as Montana digitized its records — meaning the closing evidence almost never survived.

Genealogy Narrowed the Family Tree

Stallsmith was never named in the original investigation and only became a suspect decades later.

According to Forensic Magazine's account, the Yellowstone County Sheriff's Office formed its Cold Case Unit in 2012 and selected nine cases based on solvability; in 2023 it brought Contreraz's case to Parabon Nanolabs, whose genetic genealogy work produced the first-ever list of potential leads.

By December 2024, investigators had narrowed to two brothers with Billings ties, and samples from relatives across the country eliminated one brother and confirmed the family line — leaving the deceased Angelo J. Stallsmith Sr. as the prime suspect.

Proving It When the Suspect Is Dead

With the suspect identified but dead since 1990 and cremated, forensic scientist Suzanna Ryan of Pure Gold Forensics had to get creative.

According to Forensic Magazine, she asked whether Stallsmith had ever been arrested — Yellowstone County documented 19 law enforcement contacts between 1966 and 1989 — and then whether fingerprint cards survived.

In May 2025, Billings Police and the Montana State Crime Lab sent booking cards to the lab, where DNA on the card dated November 11, 1982 was matched to the unidentified male DNA recovered from the victim's body in 1978, then confirmed with an FBI-sourced descendant sample.

Who Stallsmith Was — and Who Corina Was

The Billings Gazette reports there was no evidence Stallsmith and Corina had any previous contact, and YCSO Captain Daniel Paris said the two were unknown to each other.

Stallsmith was 29 the night of the killing, spent much of his life in and out of incarceration — including a sentence at California's San Quentin, from which he escaped in 1972 before being caught in Kansas — and died at a Billings hospital in 1990 at 41.

Corina, born in 1962, had moved from Cleveland to Billings as a toddler, attended Our Lady of Guadalupe parish, and dropped out of Billings Senior High in April 1978 after a year in which her mother and half-sister both died.

What Comes Next for the Unit

With Thursday's announcement, the Yellowstone County Cold Case Unit has closed three of its nine selected cases, and Billings-area outlets report six remain open — including the 2000 death of Jeanette and the killing of Marsha Helgeson, stabbed and beaten months before Corina and left on Alkali Creek Road.

Sheriff O'Donnell said the unit "does not forget" its victims, their families and the community, and 42 current and former officers from 10 agencies contributed to the Contreraz investigation.

Sources

  1. bozemandailychronicle.com › Yellowstone County cold case closed after nearly 50 years
  2. billingsgazette.com › 'It's finally over': Yellowstone County cold case closed after nearly 50 years
  3. forensicmag.com › DNA from 1982 Fingerprint Booking Card Solves Cold Case

More on True Crime