Civic Groups' Suit Shields Mail Ballots Through Nov. 3
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Mail Voting
- Usps
- Elections 2026
A preliminary injunction won by voter service groups bars USPS from refusing mail ballots through the November 3 election as states begin mailing.
What happened
A federal District Court issued a preliminary injunction blocking the U.S. Postal Service from enforcing key parts of a rule that would have operationalized President Trump's March 31 executive order restricting mail voting.
Under the rule, USPS would have refused to deliver mail ballots to certain voters.
The new element since the appeals-court ruling is the winning lawsuit itself: a coalition of nonpartisan civic organizations — the League of Women Voters of Massachusetts, the League of Women Voters, Association of Americans Resident Overseas, U.S. Vote Foundation, OCA – Asian Pacific American Advocates, and Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc. — secured the order, represented by the ACLU, Brennan Center for Justice, Legal Defense Fund, Advancing Justice – AAJC, and LatinoJustice PRLDEF.
Why the court acted
The court found the rule likely unconstitutional and unlawful, and warned that enforcing it would make voter disenfranchisement "practically inevitable."
Members were "threatened with grave harm, namely disenfranchisement, if they do not receive a mail ballot from their local election official," the court wrote, calling that threat imminent.
The panel noted there is no record evidence of past fraud or a likelihood of impending fraud tied to the midterms, and concluded that allowing the rule to take effect would likely disenfranchise millions of voters while providing minimal — if any — gains in combating fraud.
The injunction runs through the November 3, 2026 election and dissolves a temporary restraining order the administration had asked the Supreme Court to stay.
The rule's heavy lift
The USPS rule would require states to follow federal guidelines for designing ballot envelopes, create unique Intelligent Mail barcodes for every ballot, and upload an advance list of all mail voters to a new federal portal that was not yet operational when litigation reached the courts.
Dozens of state and local officials told the court in detail that compliance before November would be impossible; only one state claimed it could likely comply.
CalMatters reports that a postal service whistleblower asserted the portal's development was "rushed" and "risky and haphazard" due to an "impossible timeframe," citing a late-August letter from Sen. Richard Blumenthal warning of a "catastrophic failure" that could derail the midterms.
The constitutional stakes
The case raises a broader question than this year's ballots: how far a president can use federal agencies to influence election procedures traditionally controlled by states.
Law Commentary reports that the First Circuit panel concluded the rule likely regulates the "manner" of congressional elections — authority the Constitution's Elections Clause gives to states and Congress, not to an executive agency acting without specific congressional authorization.
General postal statutes under 39 U.S.C. §§ 401 and 404 were deemed insufficient to show Congress delegated its election power. Plaintiffs' counsel put it plainly: USPS has no authority in the Constitution or federal law over how states administer mail voting.
States keep mailing
Despite the litigation, election machinery is already running.
CalMatters reports that California counties are preparing to mail ballots by the state's Oct. 5 deadline, that most counties already use compliant envelope designs, and that officials are urging voters to vote early and use drop boxes and in-person sites.
Santa Cruz County Registrar Tricia Webber said counties have "contingency plans or disaster plans" in place, and some counties are exploring pop-up stations and a votemobile.
The San Joaquin Valley Sun reports that Delaware and North Carolina began mailing absentee ballots despite the ongoing litigation, and nearly one-third of U.S. voters are expected to vote by mail, per CalMatters citing AP.
What comes next
Nevada Secretary of State Cisco Aguilar told KTNV that "the President's objective is to cause chaos in the hope that voters will give up," praising the court for blocking "yet another attempt to upend our elections."
CalMatters notes the confusion may backfire by pushing more voters to cast ballots early.
Sources
- brennancenter.org › Federal Court Blocks U.S. Postal Service from Interfering with Mail Ballots in November Election
- upnorthlive.com › Appeals court upholds block on new USPS mail-in voting restrictions
- calmatters.org › With mail-in rules uncertain, here's how Californians can prepare to vote in November
- lawcommentary.com › Appeals Court Blocks Trump Mail-Ballot Rules as Supreme Court Weighs Presidential Power Over Elections
- ktnv.com › Federal judge blocks mail ballot rules, Nevada Secretary of State responds