Supreme Court Lets New Hampshire Bar Student IDs for Voting
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- Voting Rights
- New Hampshire
The Supreme Court will let New Hampshire bar student IDs as voting ID for the November election.
What Happened
The Supreme Court cleared the way for New Hampshire to bar the use of student IDs as valid photo ID required to obtain a ballot.
In a brief, unsigned order on Thursday, the justices paused a ruling by U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante, citing the principle that lower federal courts should ordinarily not alter election rules on the eve of an election.
The one-paragraph order stayed Laplante's ruling while the state's appeal moves forward.
Why It Is Surprising
The ruling's scope goes beyond the state law itself. While a statute restricting student IDs as a primary form of identification was already on the books, the Supreme Court's decision means potential voters also cannot use them as backups when seeking to establish their identities.
This broader effect was the subject of Laplante's October 2 order, which put Secretary of State David Scanlan's guidance on hold because it went further than the statute by barring student IDs for any purpose.
The Purcell Principle Dispute
The unsigned order invoked the Purcell principle, which holds that courts should not change election rules close to an election.
According to SCOTUSblog, Scanlan argued the district court's order required the state to undo steps taken since April, including published student voting guides, updated polling place posters, website updates, social media outreach, and radio ads.
The Coalition for Open Democracy countered that the judge did not block a state law but instead enforced the legislature's statutes against executive guidance exceeding their reach.
Jackson's Lone Dissent
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the sole dissenter. According to NBC News, she wrote that she would not disturb a clearly justifiable federal court order issued to ensure the public receives accurate information about a state's electoral processes.
SCOTUSblog reports she argued that when a federal court determines material misrepresentations are being made about a state's election rules, an injunction against that conduct does not contribute to public confusion but prevents it.
The Stakes
The dispute arises from HB 323, a New Hampshire law passed in April that removed student IDs from the list of acceptable identification when requesting a ballot.
The Coalition for Open Democracy, a nonprofit that helps high schools run voter-registration drives, challenged the law in federal court, arguing it burdens the right to vote and was intended to discriminate against young voters.
NBC News notes the ballot includes a closely watched Senate race between Republican John E. Sununu and Democratic Rep. Chris Pappas for the seat held by retiring Sen. Jeanne Shaheen.
What Comes Next
According to NewsCord, New Hampshire Attorney General John Formella welcomed the decision, saying it would help prevent uncertainty for voters and election officials, and that further guidance will be issued to local election officials.
The Supreme Court's stay determines which rules apply while the appeal proceeds but does not settle whether the challenged restrictions are ultimately lawful. The case continues as Scanlan v.