Clancy Defense Reverses Course: Now Argues She Didn't Kill Kids
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- True Crime
- Lindsay Clancy
- Mistrial
- Postpartum Psychosis
After admitting at trial that she killed her three children, Lindsay Clancy's lawyer argued in court there is insufficient evidence she committed the killings.
A striking turn in Plymouth
At the first hearing since her September 4 mistrial, defense attorney Kevin Reddington argued there is not enough evidence to prove Lindsay Clancy killed her three children, asking Judge William Sullivan to acquit her.
"This entire case is based on speculation," Reddington told the court, according to NPR.
Why the reversal, and why it's surprising
The Boston Globe reports Reddington argued Clancy was forced to admit to the killings to pursue an insanity defense because Judge Sullivan denied the defense's request for a bifurcated trial, in which jurors would first decide guilt and only then criminal responsibility.
He asked the judge for a directed verdict of not guilty and offered no alternative theory about who might be responsible.
Prosecutors: 'laughable'
Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham called the argument "laughable," noting per the Boston Globe that the defense repeatedly stipulated at trial to physical evidence showing Clancy killed the children in the basement of their Duxbury home.
Prosecutors maintain Clancy knew her actions were wrong when she strangled the children with exercise bands after sending her husband to pick up medicine and dinner, and in court papers filed Monday recapped their position that the evidence was sufficient to convict.
The holdout juror fight
The jury split 11 to 1 in Clancy's favor, deadlocked after roughly 39 hours of deliberation over seven days.
Her attorneys argue the lone holdout, identified by the Boston Globe as Michael Desronvil, refused to follow the law on reasonable doubt and should have been removed, and have asked the judge to investigate his questionnaire answers, cellphone use during deliberations, and an alleged undisclosed restraining order.
Desronvil says through his lawyer he had no doubts about his stance, telling Fox News' "Hannity" the focus should return to "the three angels."
Double jeopardy and dismissal
Clancy's legal team, including attorney Martin G. Weinberg per the Boston Globe, has also moved to drop the murder charges on double jeopardy grounds, arguing she should not face a second trial when 11 jurors were poised to find her not guilty by reason of insanity.
Prosecutors oppose that motion, arguing per the National News Desk report carried by ABC7 Amarillo that the judge should assess the case on trial evidence alone, without considering disputed information about jury deliberations.
What comes next
Judge Sullivan took the acquittal motion under advisement and set a November 2 hearing to take up the flurry of pending motions, including the double-jeopardy claim, the holdout juror inquiry, a defense request to unseal deliberation records, and a prosecutors' requested gag order, per the Boston Globe and The Guardian.
Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz has not said whether prosecutors will retry Clancy on first-degree murder, pursue lesser charges, or drop the case. Clancy remains charged and is expected to stay at a psychiatric hospital until her case is resolved.
Sources
- npr.org › Lindsay Clancy's lawyer now questions whether she killed her 3 children
- bostonglobe.com › Lindsay Clancy 'had no memory' of killing her children, lawyer says
- abc7amarillo.com › Lindsay Clancy's attorney says there's no evidence she killed her children
- theguardian.com › Lindsay Clancy returns to court as lawyer asks judge to find her not guilty