Clancy Mistrial: 11-1 Deadlock, Retrial Now Undecided
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- True Crime
- Lindsay Clancy
- Mistrial
- Postpartum Psychosis
- Retrial
Lindsay Clancy's murder trial ended in an 11-1 mistrial, and a judge has denied her bid for a not guilty finding as a retrial hangs undecided.
An 11-to-1 deadlock ends the trial without a verdict
After seven days and more than 36 hours of deliberation, Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case on September 4, 2026, with the jury split 11 to 1, according to Brewtiful Living's case-file timeline.
Eleven jurors favored not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility; a lone holdout did not.
Brewtiful Living reports the foreperson's note said the holdout had 'made statements acknowledging doubt but refuses to apply it to the verdict,' and the judge declined the defense's request to question that juror. A last-minute emergency petition to the state's Supreme Judicial Court was denied.
Why the jury question was never 'did she do it'
The defense never disputed that Clancy caused the deaths of Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months old, in Duxbury, Massachusetts on January 24, 2023.
Brewtiful Living explains the jury instead weighed whether mental illness left her without 'substantial capacity' to know what she was doing was wrong or to stop herself — Massachusetts's standard for lack of criminal responsibility, which can still mean psychiatric commitment.
Each child carried four possible outcomes: first-degree murder, second-degree murder, manslaughter, or not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility.
Prosecutors argued postpartum psychosis did not erase legal responsibility; the defense built its insanity case on her psychiatric treatment in the months before the deaths.
The judge's October 1 ruling keeps the case alive
On October 1, Judge William F. Sullivan denied the defense's motion for a required finding of not guilty, writing there was evidence 'that would permit a rational trier of fact to find beyond a reasonable doubt the elements of the charge,' per Brewtiful Living's timeline.
That ruling matters because the defense's first route to ending the case — insufficient evidence — has now failed.
Its remaining path is a double jeopardy motion arguing the mistrial was declared improperly, which the same report says will be argued at a November 2, 2026 hearing alongside questions about the holdout juror's conduct and possibly a retrial schedule.
What comes next: a retrial, lesser charges, or nothing
Nobody knows whether Clancy will be retried — Brewtiful Living reports Plymouth County DA Timothy Cruz's office is conducting 'a very thorough review' and could try her again on first-degree murder, pursue lesser charges like second-degree murder or manslaughter, or decline to go forward.
Clancy remains charged with murder and in custody.
The case's surrounding drama has kept it in the headlines: Patrick Clancy testified as the prosecution's first witness, married Dr. Rachel Danis in April 2026, and gave a joint 60 Minutes interview two weeks after the mistrial, while juror Nick Dargie publicly criticized the silent holdout.
For trial coverage, SiriusXM's Law&Crime channel, created by Dan Abrams, offers 24/7 true-crime programming on channel 793.