Appeals Court Blocks Trump Mail-Ballot Rules for Fall
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Elections
- Supreme Court
- Mail Voting
- Usps
The First Circuit upheld an injunction blocking USPS ballot-envelope and barcode rules for November, leaving an emergency appeal pending at the Supreme Court.
What happened: appeals court keeps USPS election rule on hold
A federal appeals court has refused to let the Trump administration enforce new nationwide mail-ballot requirements for the November midterms.
On Thursday, Law Commentary reports, the First U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a preliminary injunction blocking key parts of a Postal Service rule that would require states to use federally approved ballot envelopes, place voter-specific barcodes on election mail, and upload voter information to a USPS database before ballots could be delivered.
The three-judge panel concluded the rule likely regulates the "manner" of congressional elections — authority the Constitution gives to states and Congress, not to an executive agency acting without specific congressional authorization.
Why the timing is so unusual
The Postal Service issued its final rule on August 26 — only days before some states were scheduled to begin sending midterm ballots, according to Law Commentary.
The requirements trace back to President Trump's executive order on citizenship verification and election integrity, but the logistics were already unworkable: the online portal for uploading voter data was not operational when the litigation reached the court, and the district court found states could not realistically implement the system before November 3.
U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani issued the preliminary injunction on September 4, and the administration immediately appealed — landing the dispute in court while mail voting was already underway in parts of the country.
The evidence: postal authority, not election power
The First Circuit leaned on the Elections Clause, which gives state legislatures — and Congress — control over the "Times, Places and Manner" of congressional elections.
Law Commentary reports the panel pointed to the rule's title, "Ballot Mail for Federal Elections," its exclusive application to election mail, and its requirement that state officials take specific actions before ballots move through the postal system, finding those features likely amount to election regulation rather than an ordinary postal rule.
The court held that general grants of postal authority under 39 U.S.C. §§ 401 and 404 were insufficient to show Congress had delegated part of its constitutional election power to USPS. It also noted the government produced no record evidence of past mail-ballot fraud or an impending fraud threat.
The stakes for voters and election offices
Law Commentary reports the panel concluded that enforcing the rule now could disenfranchise millions of voters while producing at most minimal fraud-prevention gains, and that nearly one-third of U.S. voters are expected to cast ballots by mail in the midterms, per Associated Press reporting.
The dispute also lands amid broader calendar pressure on election administrators: Votebeat's national reporting describes officials racing ballot deadlines, including military and overseas voting, and quotes Harvard Election Law Clinic director Ruth Greenwood urging courts to weigh "what is going to be the most straightforward thing for election administrators and voters" as November approaches.
Noncompliant election mail could have been denied delivery under the rule.
The administration's response
The administration is not accepting the ruling.
Law Commentary reports that Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed the government's latest reply on Thursday, and that USPS and other federal officials have filed an emergency application asking the justices to stay the September 4 injunction and allow the rule to take effect.
The government argues USPS possesses express congressional authority to regulate envelopes and the information necessary for mail delivery, maintaining the rule is a valid exercise of federal postal power even though it affects ballots.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, who handles emergency matters from the First Circuit, requested responses from the challengers before the application is considered further.
What comes next
Law Commentary reports the Supreme Court's docket showed no ruling on the emergency application as of Friday, and an order could come quickly given that ballots are already moving.
The First Circuit denied requests to suspend the injunction during the litigation, concluding the administration had not shown a strong likelihood of ultimately winning — but the justices could change that result on the stay request.
Votebeat notes the broader concern extends beyond any single case: as Election Day nears nationwide, courts have shrinking room to make changes without disrupting election preparations.
Whatever the justices decide, Law Commentary observes, the underlying dispute over where postal authority ends and election regulation begins is likely to outlast the 2026 election.
Separately, SCOTUSblog reports the court is also weighing three 9/11-related petitions at its September 28 "long conference," adding to a busy fall calendar.