Report: Peltola Allies Ran Secret 'Ballot Composition' Project
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- Alaska
- 2026 Midterms
- Mary Peltola
The Times reports Peltola allies secretly put a second Dan Sullivan on Alaska's Senate ballot; Trump's DOJ is suing to block certification.
Two Dan Sullivans, One Race, and a Secret Recruitment Effort
Alaska's Nov. 3 Senate ballot features incumbent Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, Democratic challenger Mary Peltola — and a second, unrelated Dan Sullivan.
Dan J. Sullivan is a retired teacher from Petersburg, a fishing village reachable only by air and sea, who switched his registration to Republican just before the filing deadline (and has since reverted to unaffiliated).
According to a New York Times investigation republished by The Seattle Times, a Peltola staff member was told in summer 2025 to comb voter records for people named Dan Sullivan, and the retired teacher entered the race months later. The effort was internally called the "ballot composition project."
Why the Alleged Plot Is So Explosive
The Senate seat could decide chamber control, and polls suggest Alaska is one of Democrats' best chances to turn a red seat blue — making any maneuver to shave votes off the incumbent's total nationally consequential.
The Times describes an operation that went beyond one name: a Midwestern operative, Jerid Kurtz, allegedly traversed the state under the fake name "Zane," pitching would-be candidates over beers at brew pubs, and the group even considered forming a new political party.
Trump called the effort a "FRAUD ON THE AMERICAN PUBLIC" and demanded both Peltola and the "fake" Sullivan be removed from the ballot.
The Evidence, and What Everyone Denies
The Times says its reporting rests on interviews with 12 people who participated in or were told of the plan, plus dozens of internal text messages and documents prepared for a potential lawsuit.
Text messages reviewed by the Times show Peltola campaign and DSCC officials communicating about the project for months, and a pro-Peltola super PAC, 49th State PAC, reportedly paid about $87,000 this fall to Wingspan Strategies, a firm co-owned by Kurtz — which the PAC denies.
The Peltola campaign and the DSCC both deny any involvement, Dan J. Sullivan has long maintained he is running in good faith, and key source Elisa Rios tried to retract her statements ahead of publication.
Trump's DOJ Sues to Block Certification
At Trump's direction, the Justice Department filed a federal lawsuit last week seeking to block Alaska from certifying results if Sen. Sullivan loses by a margin smaller than Dan J. Sullivan's vote total — on the theory those ballots came from confused voters.
Democrats and Alaska's Republican-led state government have moved to dismiss the suit, and a federal judge fast-tracked the dispute.
Election law experts quoted in the pack are skeptical: Harvard's Nicholas Stephanopoulos says the National Voter Registration Act gives federal authorities no such power, and former DOJ attorney David Becker calls it purely a matter of state law.
A Cato Institute fellow called the suit "destined for defeat."
What Happens Before Election Day
The court fight may only matter in a photo finish — Sullivan's last Senate win came by 45,000 votes, though this cycle the Cook Political Report rates the race a toss-up and the Center for Politics calls it "leans Democrat," with Peltola's lead shrinking to about 2 points.
Meanwhile, Alaska's top-four, ranked-choice system keeps making such plays easy: both parties have exploited it before, including the state GOP's 2024 effort to keep a second Democrat on the ballot against Peltola, and the Alaska Supreme Court already ruled in June there was no legal basis to remove Dan J. Sullivan.
Election Day is less than a week away.