Banned Reporters Rejoin White House After Judge's Order

A federal judge ordered CNN, MS NOW and Politico reinstated at the White House, calling Trump's press ban likely unconstitutional, though exclusion persisted.

@sharedot

Banned Reporters Rejoin White House After Judge's Order

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Press Freedom
  • White House
  • First Amendment

A federal judge ordered CNN, MS NOW and Politico reinstated at the White House, calling Trump's press ban likely unconstitutional, though exclusion persisted.

What happened

CNN, MS NOW and Politico journalists were allowed back onto the White House grounds on Thursday, nearly a week after President Trump banned the three outlets.

U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly issued a temporary restraining order restoring their access for 14 days while the litigation proceeds, writing that Trump's directive was most likely unconstitutional because the credentials were revoked without due process.

According to NBC News, the administration's court filing described how press operations staff were told shortly after 7 a.m. to restore access by turning on the reporters' hard badges, and the Secret Service confirmed the passes were back on within hours.

Why it is surprising

Kelly rejected the White House's national security justification, writing that the stories cited in the administration's letters were routine and that Trump had instead focused publicly on the alleged negativity and untruthfulness of the outlets' reporting.

Attorney Ted Boutrous, representing the news organizations, called the decision 'a strong ruling vindicating freedom of the press, due process and the rule of law.'

Compliance lagged the order

Despite the overnight ruling, implementation was chaotic: MS NOW reports that reporters were turned away early Thursday, with some passes confiscated by the Secret Service, prompting a notice of noncompliance and a deadline for the administration to respond by 12:30 p.m.

By late morning the badges were returned and MS NOW's Laura Barrón-López reported live from the northwest gate. But hours later, MS NOW and CNN journalists were denied entry to the state dinner arrival ceremony for Chinese President Xi Jinping, with no credentials issued despite their RSVP requests.

The evidence and the legal case

The lawsuit argues Trump violated the First Amendment by retaliating against coverage he disliked, citing his Truth Social post blaming 'constant reporting FAKE NEWS!' and his remark that 'I don't want them in my office.'

The White House countered in letters to the outlets that they published 'sensitive security information, and misinformation,' a claim Kelly found thinly supported.

According to MS NOW, dozens of media organizations, including NBCUniversal, plus the White House Correspondents' Association, filed an amicus brief calling the ban 'transparently viewpoint discriminatory.'

The stakes for press access

An editorial from WBAL-TV's parent Hearst Television argues the First Amendment protects the public's right to receive information, warning that when government can remove news organizations because it dislikes their reporting, 'fewer questions can mean less information, less information can mean less accountability.'

The dispute also rippled into coverage of the Xi state visit: per Yahoo News, the four other broadcast networks declined to provide video-pool coverage in solidarity with CNN, leaving no major-network live broadcast of the arrival ceremony Trump called 'made for television.'

What comes next

Kelly declined an emergency hearing as moot once passes were restored and set briefing deadlines on the outlets' request for a preliminary injunction, indicating a longer-term ruling isn't expected until after Oct. 5, per MS NOW.

NBC News notes Trump previously indicated he would appeal any ruling against him, and the administration maintains that White House access is 'a privilege — not a right.'

Boutrous told MS NOW the case is 'the Acosta case times at least 78,' with 78 journalists stripped of passes without notice over the content of their reporting.

Sources

  1. nbcnews.com › CNN, MS NOW and Politico allowed back at the White House after judge blocked Trump's ban
  2. ms.now › MS NOW, CNN and Politico regain White House access after judge orders press passes restored
  3. wbaltv.com › Editorial: Free press controversy at the White House
  4. yahoo.com › CNN, MS NOW and Politico reporters allowed back into White House after being briefly blocked despite judge's order
  5. cbsnews.com › Trump welcomes China's Xi for state dinner at White House

More on Politics