DNA Break Ends 40-Year Virginia Beach Cold Case

Charles Berry, 66, was arrested in Connecticut for the 1986 rape and murder of 22-year-old Roberta Walls after forensic genealogy cracked the case.

@sharedot

DNA Break Ends 40-Year Virginia Beach Cold Case

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • True Crime
  • Cold Case
  • Forensic Genealogy
  • Virginia Beach

Charles Berry, 66, was arrested in Connecticut for the 1986 rape and murder of 22-year-old Roberta Walls after forensic genealogy cracked the case.

An arrest four decades in the making

Virginia Beach police announced that Charles Berry, 66, of Newington, Connecticut, was arrested Monday in connection with the 1986 rape and murder of 22-year-old Roberta Walls, according to ABC News. Walls' body was discovered on May 15, 1986, in a field behind an elementary school.

Berry is charged with rape and capital murder in the commission of a rape, and he is being held in custody in Connecticut, where the Newington Police Department confirmed the arrest. Court records indicate it is not clear whether he has an attorney.

Why this arrest is so striking

The surprise is how thoroughly the suspect had escaped detection for forty years.

Police Chief Paul Neudigate said at a news conference that it was 'incredibly scary for the community' that someone who would rape and murder someone forty years earlier had been living freely in society, ABC News reports.

According to the report, investigators said Berry appears not to have known Walls before the killing, and he had never previously been on the police's radar. He had been stationed in the Virginia Beach area as a U.S. Navy sailor at the time of the murder, police said.

The evidence trail: DNA, dead ends, genealogy

The case shows how forensic genealogy can revive work that stalled for decades. According to ABC News, Capt. Michele Wyatt said a male DNA profile was developed in 2001 and entered into the national DNA databank, but produced no match.

During the investigation, DNA from more than 30 males was compared with the offender's profile, and all were eliminated.

In 2023, the Virginia Beach Police Department received grant funding to pursue forensic genealogy leads, which pointed to a possible suspect with strong ties to the area during the relevant period. A direct DNA comparison then identified Berry as the source of the profile.

Closure for one family, open questions elsewhere

The department said the breakthrough is 'a powerful testament to the relentless persistence of our detectives, who refused to let Roberta be forgotten,' expressing hope that the arrest brings peace to the Walls family, ABC News reports.

The case is a reminder of how many cold cases still wait on the same tools: the FBI's Kansas City office is separately appealing to the public for information about Barbara and Jeremiah Hudson, found shot to death inside a Green Ridge, Missouri, house fire on July 22, 2013, a case still unsolved after more than 13 years, per 100.9 The Eagle.

Tips in that case can be submitted at 1-844-458-6622 or missouricoldcase@fbi.gov.

Sources

  1. abcnews.com › Man arrested in young woman's 1986 cold case rape, murder in Virginia Beach
  2. 101theeagle.com › Missouri Cold Case: FBI Still Searching for Clues 13 Years Later

More on True Crime