Judge Bars Kennedy Center Demolition Without 30 Days' Notice

A federal judge ordered the Kennedy Center to give 30 days' notice before any major physical changes, hours after Trump said it could be 'ripped down.'

@sharedot

Judge Bars Kennedy Center Demolition Without 30 Days' Notice

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Theater
  • Kennedy Center
  • Trump
  • Federal Court

A federal judge ordered the Kennedy Center to give 30 days' notice before any major physical changes, hours after Trump said it could be 'ripped down.'

What Happened

On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper ordered the Kennedy Center to provide 30 days' notice before making any major physical changes to the building, explicitly including demolition.

The ruling, reported by PBS, CBS News, CBC, and the AP-derived Sentinel Colorado, came less than 24 hours after President Trump said the center could end up being 'ripped down,' and after photos showed him aboard Air Force One looking at a document that said 'Kennedy Center Demolished.'

Cooper said his order was meant to 'avoid any confusion on that score given more recent events,' including the sudden closure of the building to the public on Wednesday.

Why It's Surprising

A performing arts center is not usually the subject of an emergency court order about its own physical survival.

The board, chaired by Trump and filled with his allies, voted Tuesday to close the venue indefinitely for repairs only hours after Cooper blocked it from returning Trump's name to the building, ruling that nothing could happen 'without Congress's blessing.'

Rep. Joyce Beatty, an Ohio Democrat and ex officio board member, argued in court filings reported by CBS News that the temporary closure was 'a plain pretext to justify shutting down the Center permanently.'

Her filing also noted a witness account of a forklift striking the building's pillars several times, which CBS News reports as part of her evidence.

The Safety Evidence

Kennedy Center executive director Matt Floca said in court filings that 'acute risks to public safety resulting from continued structural deterioration' necessitated a temporary closure of most public spaces, per PBS and CBS News.

He told staff the closure would last at least seven days, evaluated week to week, and stressed it was 'a distinct decision by management' separate from the board's renovation vote.

CBS News reports that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick shared photos of plaster falling from the ceiling, which he said nearly hit a security guard, after a partial ceiling collapse earlier this month.

Fencing went up around the main building Wednesday, blocking vehicle and pedestrian access, according to the AP report carried by Sentinel Colorado.

The Stakes for a Living Memorial

Kennedy, sits at the center of a fight over money, names, and national memory. Congress has allocated $257 million for repairs, but Trump said the work would only happen if the board could move forward with plans to add his name.

Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Restored and Renovated By President Donald J. Trump' on the facade, with a second inscription if the Trump Kennedy Center Fund reached $100 million, plus a plaza renaming. Cooper shot all of that down Tuesday.

Kerry Kennedy, one of JFK's nieces, accused Trump of taking the institution 'hostage,' according to WPDE, while Maria Shriver called it 'a tragedy.'

The Reactions

Barbra Streisand, a 2008 Kennedy Center honoree, told The Associated Press the dispute was 'galling and painful to witness,' saying, 'You can easily imagine my indignation at seeing this revered institution become the subject of such a bitter struggle over one man's name and unchecked ego.'

She added that her honoree recognition 'represented a belief in the importance of art to the life of a democracy.' Beatty said Trump 'threw a tantrum' after losing in court, telling CNN he 'picked the wrong person to try to attack my character.'

Activists with the group Hands Off the Arts, per Sentinel Colorado, feared demolition before the case concludes, with organizer Laura Bligh saying, 'The worst-case scenario is a wrecking ball.'

What Comes Next

The Justice Department must deliver a detailed report to Judge Cooper by next Wednesday on the 'temporary closure' and emergency repairs, CBS News reports, with the closure set to last one week 'unless extended.'

Cooper denied Beatty's request for an emergency hearing on the closure but agreed to 'make crystal clear' that his order prohibits demolition without 30 days' notice.

He has not yet ruled on whether the board's vote to close for renovations was lawful, though he must approve that decision, per CBS News and CBC.

Meanwhile, the Justice Department said the duration of the closure will be evaluated week to week, leaving open how long fencing will keep the public away from a building at the heart of a federal court fight.

Sources

  1. pbs.org › Judge orders Kennedy Center to provide 30 days' notice before making any major physical changes
  2. cbsnews.com › Kennedy Center says "nothing is being demolished" as Trump says it could be "ripped down"
  3. cbc.ca › Judge orders Kennedy Center to give 30-day notice before any major changes — including demolition
  4. sentinelcolorado.com › Fencing goes up around the main Kennedy Center building after Trump-aligned board votes to close it
  5. wpde.com › Trump says Kennedy Center could be 'ripped down' without recognition for repairs

More on Theater