Comedian Göktaş Freed After Laughing His Way Through Trial
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Comedy
- Stand Up
- Deniz Goktas
- Turkey
- Press Freedom
An Istanbul court convicted Deniz Göktaş over his 'Dead Sea' stand-up show but released him after 88 days, following a courtroom defense that had spectators in stitches.
The Verdict: Convicted, Then Walked Free
On September 28, an Istanbul court convicted 32-year-old comedian Deniz Göktaş of insulting President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, sentencing him to 11 months and 20 days, and added seven months and 15 days for insulting religious values after downgrading an incitement charge, according to Hürriyet Daily News.
The judge acquitted him of praising crime and criminals. The court then ordered his release, taking into account the 88 days he had already spent in pretrial detention, and AFP reported he walked out of Karatepe high-security prison late Monday, beaming as family and fans greeted him.
Why a Comedy Channel Cares: The Defense Was a Set
Prosecutors had singled out his description of Erdoğan as 'a shy dictator,' but he insisted 'dictator is not an insult: it is a political characterization,' and argued that a political comedy show that never mentioned Erdoğan would 'have no connection to reality.'
As he left the stand, he quipped that three months had been taken from his life but, since he quit smoking in custody, he would 'add three months to the end' of it, drawing laughter and applause.
How a Stand-Up Show Became a Criminal Case
According to DW, Göktaş was arrested on July 3, a week after posting a YouTube video of his 'Ölü Deniz' (Dead Sea) show that was watched nearly 9 million times, with shorter clips on X enjoying similar success.
DW reports that prosecutors cited more than 500 applications to prosecute him filed through the Presidential Communication Center, with Erdoğan named as sole complainant and the government-sponsored Diyanet religious authority among those providing a tipoff.
The so-called jokes about Islam that drew the incitement charge, per DW, included references to women in full-coverage swimsuits as 'divers' and 'suicide bombers who fast.'
'The Joke Hasn't Changed. The Leadership Has'
Göktaş's central argument, echoed across AFP and Turkish Minute, was that the laws protecting freedom of expression had not changed, 'but today, a comedian is sitting in a cell.' He told the court that 'the joke hasn't changed.
What has changed is the increasingly fragile leadership that can no longer tolerate the joke,' and said humor was a centuries-old part of Turkish culture with no place for 'censorship, bans or detention' for artists on stage.
DW notes Turkey routinely tries people for speech offenses, and that the prosecution echo of Erdoğan's earlier pursuit of German comedian Jan Böhmermann gives the case a familiar resonance for comedy fans.
Support in the Rain and a New Generation Watching
An AFP correspondent saw about 50 supporters gather outside the Çağlayan courthouse in pouring rain, chanting 'Deniz Göktaş is not alone!'
Among those inside were comedians from Istanbul's TuzBiber club, where Göktaş began his career in 2019, plus observers from the Dutch embassy and US consulate, according to Turkish Minute.
AFP interviewed 22-year-old aspiring comedian Fatih Yılmaz, who traveled from Alanya and said the arrest made him feel proud and determined to keep doing stand-up, while retiree Nesrin Demirkan told AFP she was outraged that Göktaş had been held in a 'well-type cell' just for doing his job.
What Comes Next: Appeal and a Finalized Sentence
The release is interim: AFP and The Straits Times report the roughly 19-month sentence becomes final only after review by an appeals court, and it was not immediately clear how long that process would take.
Under Turkish law, Hürriyet Daily News notes, prison sentences under five years may allow release rather than continued detention at the judge's discretion.
Göktaş told reporters after leaving prison, per AFP, that 'there are thousands of people like me who are being held in custody or convicted for their opinions' and that he hoped 'the time will come when we can all regain our freedom.'
His prosecution remains part of a wider pattern that Amnesty International and others track among Turkish artists and journalists.
Sources
- hurriyetdailynews.com › Istanbul court orders release of comedian after conviction
- yahoo.com › Turkish comedian convicted for Erdogan 'insult' freed pending appeal
- straitstimes.com › Turkish comedian convicted over Erdogan 'insult' but freed pending appeal
- stockholmcf.org › Turkish court convicts comedian Deniz Göktaş over stand-up show, orders release
- dw.com › Turkey: Comedian convicted for 'insulting' Erdogan in show
- turkishminute.com › Turkish court convicts comedian Deniz Göktaş over stand-up show, orders release