Critics Say SNL U.K. Has Found Its Own Voice
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Comedy
- Saturday Night Live
- Sketch Comedy
- Snl UK
The New York Times says 'Saturday Night Live U.K.' has grown past its American blueprint in seven months, even as Collider argues the U.S. show dodges its own controversies.
A Parallel-Universe Premiere That Stopped Feeling Like One
When "Saturday Night Live U.K." premiered in March, it followed the American playbook almost beat for beat: a politically timely cold open, a live band playing sketches on and offstage, a Weekend Update break, and Tina Fey as its first host.
From the moment the cast first shouted "Live from London, it's Saturday night!," The New York Times' TV critic Caroline Darya Framke writes that watching it felt like spying on a parallel universe full of potential.
The show belongs to the S.N.L. brand — Lorne Michaels executive produces it too — but without 50 years of history to shoulder, it got to start fresh, and the only question was how different it could become.
Seven Months Later: Scathing Punchlines and DIANA
According to The New York Times, the show has now established itself as more than just an experiment.
It has tweaked the inherited formats, landed what the paper calls scathing punchlines, and leaned into its Britishness — including a sketch introducing King Charles to a "Deeply Intelligent, Autonomous, Neurokinetic Android," a.k.a. DIANA.
The Times' argument is that the bones look familiar, but the cast and writers have brought the format to life in a way all their own.
For a spinoff born in the shadow of an institution, that is the reversal comedy fans were told was nearly impossible: deviation from the parent show's norms, the critic notes, is risky even for the original S.N.L.
The Contrast: Collider Says Stateside SNL Dodges Its Own Mess
Collider's reading of the Halloween episode makes the transatlantic contrast starker.
The outlet argues Inde Navarrette nailed her hosting debut — flipping Shane Gillis's October 10 monologue comments about women at the gym back at him while discussing her Rogue workout for Marvel's X-Men reboot — but questions why a 25-year-old guest host, making her debut, had to be the one answering for a controversy the show itself broadcast.
Collider reports that cast, writers, or Weekend Update could have taken up the subject, and notes Dan Levy had called for more men to speak up. Collider also says SNL U.K.'s handling of Gillis's remarks and political material makes the American show's reluctance harder to miss.
What's at Stake for Both S.N.L.s
The stakes, as the two outlets frame them, are about ownership of a joke.
Collider stresses Navarrette deserves credit and the joke was her choice, but argues SNL shouldn't need a guest host to say what its own stars could have, since Gillis's remarks were prepared material that passed the show's approval process.
The same critique extends to the desk: Collider says Michael Che's delivery on a Paddy Young-style uncomfortable Israel-Palestine-adjacent bit faltered before cutting to Colin Jost's sitcom-like reaction, draining the punchline of confidence.
Meanwhile the Times' verdict on the London version suggests the freshest thing in the franchise is the one unburdened by its traditions. Saturday Night Live airs Saturdays at 11:29 p.m.
EST on NBC, per Collider.