Elmo's Lorne Michaels Impression Stuns SNL Fans
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Comedy
- Snl
- Sesame Street
Elmo nailed a pitch-perfect Lorne Michaels impression in a Sesame Street x SNL writers' room video that fans are calling the show's best bit ever.
Muppets Invade the SNL Writers' Room
Day set the scene: "we have some new writers joining us" for a big show. Rather than pitch fresh material, Nerdist notes the muppets leaned on classic SNL sketches — Cookie Monster as Matt Foley, Padilla and Grover revisiting "Haircut," and Elmo's Domingo riff, "Elmingo."
Sherman later confessed on Instagram, "I cried when I met them."
The Elmo-as-Lorne Moment Fans Can't Stop Watching
The breakthrough bit, per NBC, came when Elmo pulled out a pitch-perfect Lorne Michaels impression: "Well, you know, it's the first time we were all together — Paul and Paul and Snuffleupagus."
Nerdist went further, calling it possibly "the greatest moment in both Sesame Street and Saturday Night Live's respective histories" and hoping for a dinner sketch pairing Lorne, Elmo, the two Pauls, and Snuffleupagus.
Yahoo reports fans on X agreed, with comments like "That Lorne impression has no right being so good" and calls to book Elmo as a host.
Cookie Monster's Matt Foley and Oscar's Debbie Downer
The deep-cut references kept coming. NBC reports Cookie Monster channeled Chris Farley's motivational speaker Matt Foley, cheap suit and all: "you'll be doing a lot of cookie eating when you're living in a van down by the river!" before collapsing onto the table.
According to NBC, Oscar the Grouch accidentally stumbled into a Debbie Downer tribute, complete with sad trombone and zoom-in, then asked, "What was that?" Nerdist adds that Sarah Sherman found her soul mates by creating a Three-Headed Monster with the gang.
Padilla and Grover also bonded over their "salon" haircuts, matching her Season 51 "Haircut" sketch with Glen Powell, NBC says.
Why Elmo's Lorne Landing Surprised Everyone
Yahoo's writer admits the impression blindsided them: never in their "wildest dreams" did they expect the diminutive muppet to mimic SNL's creator, and they argue puppeteer Ryan Dillon deserves real credit for the skill it takes to voice one character doing an impression of another.
Yahoo also frames Elmo as a proven viral engine, noting his 2025 grouchy-naptime confession, his NBA Finals well-wishes to the Knicks and Spurs, and his long-running beef with Rocco — a rivalry SNL even nodded to when Elmo nixed Rocco jokes, per NBC, just as Padilla arrived dressed as Zoe's pet rock.
What Comes Next: Snack-urday Night
The bit's stinger, NBC reports: every Sesame Street character — plus Kenan Thompson — dozed off before airtime.
"It's past their bedtime," Sherman pointed out, while Cookie Monster mumbled "Live from New York, it's Snack-urday night" and Thompson riffed on his What's Up With That? character Diondre Cole.
Nerdist hopes the muppets stick around Studio 8H long enough for that Lorne dinner sketch, and Yahoo wants Elmo doing his Michaels impression in front of Michaels himself. SNL airs Saturdays at 11:30 p.m.
ET on NBC, with Sesame Street now streaming on Netflix and PBS Kids stations.