Oswalt, Wolf Say Maniscalco Squeezed 500 Comics Off SiriusXM

Patton Oswalt and Michelle Wolf are urging Sebastian Maniscalco to reverse his SiriusXM channel takeover that squeezed 500 comics off the air.

@sharedot

Oswalt, Wolf Say Maniscalco Squeezed 500 Comics Off SiriusXM

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Comedy
  • Stand Up Comedy
  • Siriusxm
  • Sebastian Maniscalco
  • Patton Oswalt

Patton Oswalt and Michelle Wolf are urging Sebastian Maniscalco to reverse his SiriusXM channel takeover that squeezed 500 comics off the air.

What Happened: Raw Dog Becomes Maniscalco's Channel

The move drew little attention at launch, but this week it exploded into an open feud, as Patton Oswalt, Michelle Wolf, Margaret Cho, Liz Miele, Kyle Kinane and Greg Stone posted Instagram videos calling on Maniscalco to restore the programming that once filled the channel.

Oswalt told Maniscalco directly that '500 of them have been booted off of Sirius' and that he 'can easily reverse this decision,' asking him to let young comics get their checks again.

Why It's Surprising: A Non-Controversial Comic in the Hot Seat

Deadline notes that Maniscalco 'isn't widely viewed as a controversial comic,' making the wave of peer criticism unusual — this is an arena-filling headliner with no history of feuds now facing public appeals from colleagues rather than critics.

The surprise is compounded by the mechanism: nobody is alleging malice. Comics including Oswalt and Stone explicitly say they assume Maniscalco 'didn't mean to do anything bad' and 'didn't notice' the effects of the rebrand, framing it as a fixable mistake rather than a scandal.

Greg Stone even appealed 'as one Italian coming to another Italian' to reverse the change.

The Evidence: 812 Comics to 275 in Six Months

Yahoo reports that Stand Up for Stand Up, a comedy advocacy group, used data from XMPlaylist to show distinct comics receiving spins on the channel plunged from 812 in April to 275 in September — a drop of roughly 66% — even as total monthly plays stayed roughly flat.

According to the group, more than 75% of plays now go to the top 50 artists and celebrity acts, and comics previously earned $15 per 'spin' of their set.

Liz Miele says Raw went 'from playing 800 working class comedians to now playing less than 300 celebrity comedians like Joan Rivers, Johnny Carson, Bob Hope, Norm Macdonald' — many of them dead.

The Video Appeal: 'Bring Back Raw Dog'

The story has been driven almost entirely by comedians' Instagram videos rather than press releases.

Greg Stone's post, titled 'Sebastian Maniscalco Is Destroying Comedy,' jokes that fans will otherwise see favorite comics 'pumping gas, waiting tables' or 'begging for change outside of… a Piggly Wiggly,' and urges listeners to call SiriusXM and demand 'Bring back Raw Dog.'

Michelle Wolf's video stresses that 'your favorite comic used to play on that channel,' while Dan Soder says the new rotation features 'very famous comics who are dead or who don't necessarily need the money,' per The Verge.

The Stakes: Royalty Checks That Kept Working Comics Working

The complaints center on money, not exposure.

Stand Up for Stand Up says Raw Dog royalties 'aids in supporting their comedy career in the form of passive royalty earnings,' and Miele calls the loss 'devastating' for 'working class comedians, people that only make money on the road, that have no safety net.'

Oswalt argues comedy stays 'dynamic and fun' only when new voices can earn while coming up. Deadline reports SiriusXM sources defended the rebrand as necessary because the old channel wasn't meeting listenership expectations, though the company has not released channel-level audience data.

What Comes Next: A Fix Maniscalco Can Reverse

Both outlets note that The Hollywood Reporter and Deadline reached out to Maniscalco's team for comment without an immediate response, and SiriusXM told them in a statement that it 'continues to invest in comedians more than any other audio platform,' pointing to its many other comedy channels.

The comics' campaign is explicitly framed as reversible: Oswalt says 'you can easily reverse this decision,' Miele says 'you can fix this,' and Stone wants fans lobbying SiriusXM directly.

Whether Maniscalco responds — and how much control he personally has over individual channel selections, which remains unclear per Yahoo — will decide if the story grows or dies this week.

Sources

  1. hollywoodreporter.com › Patton Oswalt, Michelle Wolf Call on Sebastian Maniscalco to Reverse SiriusXM Channel Takeover
  2. theverge.com › Sebastian Maniscalco's SiriusXM channel is hurting up-and-coming talent, comics say
  3. deadline.com › Sebastian Maniscalco, SiriusXM Urged To Restore Raw Dog Airplay
  4. yahoo.com › Sebastian Maniscalco takes heat from comics over SiriusXM channel shakeup

More on Comedy