Carvey 'Didn't Understand the Kerfuffle' Over Gillis' SNL Joke

Dana Carvey and David Spade defended Shane Gillis' controversial SNL monologue on their Fly on the Wall podcast, calling it simply a joke.

@sharedot

Carvey 'Didn't Understand the Kerfuffle' Over Gillis' SNL Joke

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Comedy
  • Saturday Night Live
  • Shane Gillis
  • Dana Carvey

Dana Carvey and David Spade defended Shane Gillis' controversial SNL monologue on their Fly on the Wall podcast, calling it simply a joke.

What Happened on the Fly on the Wall Podcast

On the latest episode of "Fly on the Wall," the podcast he hosts with David Spade, former Saturday Night Live star Dana Carvey said he "just didn't understand the kerfuffle" over Shane Gillis' October 10 monologue.

"To me, I just saw it as what we call — I'll just say it — a joke," Carvey said, adding, "Like, when you say jokes, you're not literally saying women are whores. You are literally joking. Isn't that kind of the idea? No? Did I just get canceled?"

Gillis' Monologue, Live From Studio 8H

Watch on YouTube · Saturday Night Live · 7:08

  1. — Thank you. Thank you, guys. I appreciate that.
  2. — I tried to go to a public gym.
  3. — My friend Joe Rogan has a private gym

Watching the clip is essential context for the split it produced: Spade says "it got some laughs" and that Gillis knew the line would be "a button-pusher, but he doesn't care," while Carvey concedes the joke probably "destroyed" in "the 10 comedy clubs he played that week" before admitting SNL was maybe "not the right place" for it.

Why the Defense From Carvey Carries Weight

As Netflix Junkie frames it, his Studio 8H pedigree gives him a perspective on the gap between club comedy and national broadcast — a joke can thrive before fans who know a comic's style, then land differently before a mixed TV audience the outlet notes skews toward young women.

Toronto Sun adds Carvey has apologized for past SNL jokes that missed, including a 1992 Sharon Stone sketch.

The Other Side: Levy, Nwodim and the Critics

The pushback was loud. Dan Levy said in an Instagram Reel that "women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores. It makes the men calling them whores misogynists," adding he was "speechless that something like that can exist on live national television."

Former SNL player Ego Nwodim posted a gym selfie captioned "whore reporting for duty," and Cecily Strong and Maren Morris mocked the bit on Instagram. Michael Che told the Today show he couldn't "criticize anybody for swinging and missing — that's comedy."

Where the Standoff Goes Next

Spade's read on SNL economics — "if something kills, it gets a pass. If something totally bombs, then they get in a lot of trouble" — suggests the fallout may hinge on whether audiences ultimately laugh.

Gillis has not addressed the controversy, there has been no new SNL episode since his monologue, and Jimmy Carr has since weighed in on video that "intent is much more important," calling Gillis "very clearly a lovely man" and joking the row just means Gillis "won't be able to go to the gym for a while."

Sources

  1. variety.com › Dana Carvey Says He 'Didn't Understand the Kerfuffle' Over Shane Gillis' 'SNL' Monologue
  2. usatoday.com › 'SNL' alum Dana Carvey doesn't get 'the kerfuffle' over Shane Gillis joke
  3. torontosun.com › Dana Carvey and David Spade defend Shane Gillis after 'SNL' uproar
  4. soapcentral.com › Jimmy Carr defends Shane Gillis following SNL monologue controversy
  5. netflixjunkie.com › Dana Carvey Pushes Back on Shane Gillis Backlash After Controversial 'SNL' Monologue

More on Comedy